Red Sox Season So Far: The Standouts, Letdowns, and In-Betweens
As the 2025 baseball season rounds the first quarter, the Boston Red Sox find themselves stuck in the middle of the standings—neither contending nor collapsing. At this rate, they seem destined for another middling 81-81 record, much like last year.
This snapshot of the season breaks down some of the best, worst, and most forgettable individual performances from the Sox so far. Despite a recent wave of negativity, it’s still early—and in baseball, it’s how you finish that really matters. History reminds us: in 2007, the Colorado Rockies stormed into the playoffs with a 20-8 September run, only to be swept by the Red Sox in the World Series.
Biggest Disappointment: Tanner Houck
Tanner Houck, an early All-Star in 2024, has seen his performance fall off a cliff. Something’s clearly been wrong, and now he’s on the injured list—echoing past cases like John Lackey’s 2009 collapse, which was later blamed on injury. If Houck ends up needing surgery, it could mean a lost season—but also hope for a strong comeback, just like Lackey in 2013.
Solid Investment: Alex Bregman
Alex Bregman’s 2019 numbers were elite, and Boston bet big on him with a $40 million investment. That gamble is paying off, as Bregman looks ready to match those stellar stats again. His performance could prompt the team to open the checkbook even more.
Most “Meh”: Trevor Story
Trevor Story continues to be streaky—hot one week, ice-cold the next. He’s not hurting the team, but he’s not elevating it either. Until prospect Marcelo Mayer arrives, Story remains a placeholder with predictable output.
Under-the-Radar Move: Carlos Narváez
In a minor trade with the Yankees, Boston acquired catcher Carlos Narváez, who stepped in after Connor Wong’s pinky injury. Narváez has shown promise on both defense and offense—he could become the primary catcher, much like Sandy León did unexpectedly in 2016.
Early Returns Mixed: Brayan Bello
Brayan Bello’s stats on the surface look great (2-0, 2.33 ERA), but dig deeper and you find red flags, like a 5.55 FIP. Bello needs longer outings to avoid straining the bullpen and to prove he’s more than just a short-inning starter.
Bright Spot: Garrett Crochet
Garrett Crochet has been a revelation, giving the Sox quality innings and shaping up as a potential All-Star and Cy Young candidate. He’s been a big win for Boston’s front office.
Setback: Garrett Whitlock
After struggling with injuries in 2023, Garrett Whitlock showed early signs of a turnaround this year—only to end up back on the IL. His stats resemble his 2021 breakout, but injuries have again derailed his progress.
A Work in Progress: Ceddanne Rafaela
Ceddanne Rafaela, known for elite defense and speed, has had a mixed season offensively. He’s still too aggressive at the plate, but his contact rate has improved. With a .250 average and more discipline, his offensive value could rise significantly.
Quiet MVP Candidate: Wilyer Abreu
Wilyer Abreu has quietly been one of Boston’s best players. He hits for power, plays excellent defense, and is on pace for a stellar 8.0 bWAR season. He’s a dark horse for team MVP—even over stars like Bregman.
